The Great Debate at Samye
The Great Debate at Samye — a philosophy story. 10 illustrated pages, narrated, on the kids shelf, free to read on Wonder Philosophy.
Page 1
Pema Yangchen trotted along the ridge of Hepori Hill with her satchel bulging and forty rolled invitation scrolls stacked high in her arms, each one taller than her forearm. She did not see the frayed rope trailing behind the yak calf until it looped itself around her ankles and arms at once. Drolma bounded forward chasing a moth, the rope snapped tight, and Pema let out a yelp as the whole armful burst loose. Scrolls cartwheeled down the steep slope like wheels, bouncing off tufts of grass, unrolling as they went. Pema scrambled after them on hands and knees, skidding on loose stones, grabbing at paper and catching only air. Down below, King Trisong Detsen turned sharply at the commotion, his turquoise earrings swinging, and stuck out his white boot just as the last scroll came spinning toward the stupas. It thudded against his toe and stopped dead, inches from rolling into the ditch.
Page 2
The round yak-hide boats bumped against the gravel landing, and the two masters stepped out onto the stones. But the rope lashing the tall scholar's travel bundle had come loose on the crossing, and when the round-bellied scholar's wooden book-chest shifted, it slid straight off the ferryman's plank into the shallow water with a heavy splash. 'Catch it before the current takes it!' cried the king, already kicking off his upturned boots and wading in, brocade sleeve soaking to the elbow. The tiny novice dropped her satchel on the gravel and plunged after him, grabbing one carved corner of the chest, while the woolly calf splashed in beside her, seizing the trailing rope in her teeth and hauling backward. The tall scholar waded knee-deep, bracing his long thin arms under the chest, and together they heaved it up the slope, dripping, onto the dry gravel. 'My poor pages,' moaned the round scholar, wringing his huge grey sleeve, but when he opened the lid, the texts inside were bone dry.
Page 3
The striped canopy over the debate ground was half-built, its poles taller than a man and its ropes stretched tight between them. Drolma, bored of waiting, wandered beneath the guy-ropes and began gnawing one thick cord with happy determination. Nobody noticed until the rope frayed through with a snap and the whole heavy awning sagged down in a slow collapsing wave, burying three startled carpenters under striped cloth. Pema dropped her satchel and ran, grabbing at fabric and hauling it up uselessly with both small arms. The king lunged to pull a carpenter free by the shoulders. Then the tall scholar stepped in, unhurried, wrapping his long fingers around one leaning pole and lifting it slowly, steadily upright, while the round teacher on the other side planted his broad bare feet and heaved his pole up all at once with a great grunting shove. Between them the canopy snapped taut again, poles standing, cloth billowing down into place, and the carpenters crawled out blinking into daylight, dusty but unharmed.
Page 4
Up near the ceiling of the scripture store, monks balanced on tall ladders and lowered rope baskets from the top pigeonholes, shelf after shelf taller than three men standing on each other's shoulders. King Trisong Detsen braced the swaying ladder foot with both hands, calling up warnings. Kamalashila reached with his long arm to steady a basket as it bumped past him, while Moheyan stood below with sleeves spread wide, ready to catch whatever fell. Then a basket tipped, spilling loose pages into the air. A thin Sanskrit sheet slid sideways, drifting toward the floorboards, and Pema flung herself flat, sliding across the wood on her knees and belly, arms stretched, catching the page just before it touched dust. Below the commotion, Drolma had found the rope's end and was calmly gnawing through the knot, her bell clonking with each tug, until the whole basket swung loose and had to be hauled tight again by three pairs of hands working together.
Page 5
The garlands went up on their cords, and for one heartbeat the whole debate ground looked perfect: two waist-high lecterns facing each other, pages stacked neat and white. Then the valley wind hit like a slammed door. Pema grabbed for the nearest stack and missed, and the pages leapt off both lecterns at once, spinning into the sky in a great flapping flock. Monks ducked, fly-whisks flailing. The king lunged and caught three pages against his chest, shouting for ropes to pin down what was left. Kamalashila threw himself flat across his own lectern, pressing the last pages down with both long arms. Moheyan spun his round fan wide trying to bat pages out of the air, catching one against its painted circle. Drolma bounded after a drifting sheet, snapping at it, her bell clonking wildly, and tangled herself in a fallen garland, dragging it skidding across the sand. Nobody stood still; everybody chased something white and spinning.
Page 6
The wind had dumped the scrolls straight into the river dunes, and now the whole crossing party scrambled up the shifting slopes after them, sand sliding out from under every footstep. Pema dropped to her knees at the crest and plunged both arms wrist-deep, dragging up a page by its corner before the dune could swallow it again. The king waded higher, boots sinking to the ankle, scooping pages two at a time and shouting their number down the slope. Moheyan had given up pockets entirely — he held his huge grey sleeves open like sacks, and Kamalashila folded his long body low, fed page after page into them, and caught two more before the next gust could snatch them away. Drolma snorted and dug with her black nose, flinging sand sideways until a whole buried chapter came up stuck together, and she trotted it proudly to the king's feet, tail pompom swinging. Everyone pushed higher up the ridge, hauling fistfuls of paper against their chests, racing the wind to the top before it could steal another page.
Page 7
The wind had dropped, but it left its mischief behind: a dozen pale pages clung to the golden deer and the dharma wheel on Jampa Ling's roof, flapping like trapped moths. The king himself dragged the tall ladder against the wall, bracing both hands against its sides and planting his boot on the bottom rung to hold it steady. Kamalashila climbed first, his long legs folding up the rungs, and from the parapet he stretched his impossibly long arm toward the nearest page, fingers just grazing it. It wasn't enough. So Moheyan knotted a sturdy rope basket, and Pema climbed in, clutching the sides as the king and Kamalashila hauled her upward hand over hand, the basket swinging past the roof's golden edge. She snatched page after page from between the deer's gilded antlers, tucking each one inside her robe. Below, Drolma barked and leapt, catching one stray page that spiraled down, pinning it proudly under her hoof until Moheyan scooped it up.
Page 8
The last page was gone — wedged tight under a flat stone, caught high in a wind-bent juniper above the cliff stairway. Pema scrambled up the loose steps first, stretching on tiptoe, but her arm fell two handspans short. The king climbed after her, boots scraping rock, and braced his broad shoulder against the trunk while Kamalashila unwound his red sash and knotted it to Moheyan's wide belt. Moheyan laughed and added his own, tying the ends with quick fat fingers, and Pema tied on her yellow waist-cord to make the line long enough. Drolma planted her hooves and leaned back against the slack, steadying the whole knotted rope with her woolly weight. Kamalashila flicked the line upward again and again until it looped the stone and tugged it loose, and the page floated down slow as a feather, spinning past juniper needles. The king caught it flat against his chest before it touched the dust, and Pema clapped both ink-stained hands over her mouth in delight.
Page 9
Pema darted across the workshop floor carrying a stack of rescued pages, and her boot caught the edge of a low stool. The clay pot of wheat paste toppled, glugging its pale glue across the plank table that reached her waist. 'Oh no, oh no!' she cried, scrambling to right it, but Moheyan just laughed through his moustache and scooped a fingerful onto a page. 'Paste is paste,' he said, slapping Sanskrit and Chinese sheets together with wide sweeps of his huge sleeves. Kamalashila held each pasted leaf flat against the table, his long fingers smoothing bubbles toward the edge. Drolma sniffed at the spill, wool dusted white, then flopped down to help press the growing stack with her whole woolly body. King Trisong Detsen hauled river stones, each as big as a melon, from a basket and stacked them atop the finished volume to squash it flat. Then, beaming, he lifted two garlands of marigold and draped one over Kamalashila's tall pointed hat and the other around Moheyan's round bald head, declaring the glued book a treasure worth celebrating.
Page 10
At the stone cairn where the road forks above the river bend, a fresh pole twice the height of the king has been dropped into its socket, and now it wobbles until Drolma plants her hooves and hauls backward on the rope looped round her chest, bell clonking with every tug. Pema scrambles underneath, both arms braced against the wood, pushing with all her small weight while the king grabs the base and jams flat stones around it to lock it steady. Up above, Kamalashila stretches his long arm along the line of flags, knotting one end around the top of the pole, while across the gap Moheyan plants his broad feet in the sand and ties the far end to a second stake, his wide sleeves flapping like extra flags themselves. The long string of colored cloth snaps taut between them, red, white, green catching the valley wind. Once it holds, everyone steps back, dusting hands on robes, and together they turn down the open river road, the braided blue water beside them and the white peaks waiting ahead.
About this story
- Audience: kids (ages 6–12)
- Format: 10 illustrated pages, narrated, on the kids shelf, free to read on Wonder Philosophy
Read Wonder Philosophy on your phone
Wonder Philosophy is available on Android and iPhone and iPad. Get Wonder Philosophy on Google Play · Get Wonder Philosophy on the App Store.