Catriona
A story of love, honour, and political danger in 18th-century Scotland
Page 1
David Balfour, now master of the House of Shaws, stood on the Calton Hill overlooking the smoky grey city of Edinburgh. He had money and a good name, but his conscience was not clear. A man he knew to be innocent, James Stewart of the Glens, was to be tried for the Appin Murder, a crime that had shaken the Highlands. David held evidence that could save him, testimony about the real killer. But to speak out was to risk his own life and fortune, placing himself against the most powerful men in Scotland. He looked down at the castle, the tall stone houses, and the winding streets, and made his choice. He would not stand by and let an innocent man hang. "It is a great risk," he said to himself, looking down at the city's sprawl, "but I will face it. I must see that justice is done." He turned his back on the wide view and began to walk down into the city.
Page 2
David was shown into the grand, book-lined office of William Grant, Lord Advocate of Scotland. The most powerful lawyer in the country sat behind a great mahogany desk, his face stern under his formal wig. Prestongrange had heard of David's intentions and did not approve. "You are a young man of property and prospects, Mr. Balfour," the Advocate began, his voice cold. "I advise you to let this matter lie. The peace of the Highlands is a delicate thing." David stood his ground before the desk. "But the man is innocent, my lord. I have proof that I must present." The Lord Advocate’s eyes narrowed, and he tapped a letter-opener on the desk. "Some truths are better left unspoken. For your own safety, and for the good of the kingdom, you will say nothing. Do you understand me?" It was not advice; it was a threat from the highest lawman in the land.
Page 3
Leaving the Lord Advocate's office, troubled, David walked through the formal gardens of the house. There, he came across a young woman with dark hair and eyes that shone with spirit. She was kneeling by a flowerbed but looked up as he approached. "You are Mr. Balfour," she said, her voice clear and proud. "I have heard of you." She introduced herself as Catriona MacGregor Drummond. David learned she was the daughter of the notorious Highland rogue, James More. Despite her family's reputation, David was immediately drawn to her fierce honesty and grace. "My father is a hunted man," she said, rising to her feet, "but he is not a bad one. He has his enemies, as all good Jacobites do." David felt his quest for justice becoming entangled with this captivating woman. "I hope I may see you again," he found himself saying. She smiled, a promise and a challenge in her eyes. "Perhaps you may," she replied, and turned back to her flowers.
Page 4
A few days later, a message arrived for David, supposedly from Catriona, asking him to meet her on the docks at Leith. His heart leapt, and he hurried to the port as dusk fell. The quayside was a noisy tangle of ropes, barrels, and the smell of tar and sea. He saw the brig *The Thistle* ready to sail on the tide. But as he searched the busy dock for Catriona, he was suddenly grabbed from behind by rough-looking sailors. "What is this?" he cried, struggling against their strong grip. "You have the wrong man!" A coarse voice laughed in his ear. "No mistake, Laird. The Lord Advocate sends his regards. You've been asking too many questions." Before he could shout for help, a sack was thrown over his head, plunging him into darkness. He felt himself being dragged up a gangplank. He had been tricked. Prestongrange was silencing him, not with a blade, but with a long voyage out of Scotland.
Page 5
The voyage was short. David was taken not to the Americas but to a grim fortress perched on a lonely, windswept rock in the middle of the sea. This was the Bass Rock, a notorious prison. He was thrown into a small, damp stone cell high up in the fortress, with only a narrow slit for a window. Through it, he could see nothing but grey sea. The hope that had filled him vanished, replaced by cold despair. James Stewart would hang, and David was powerless. He would be forgotten here, a prisoner of the state without trial or charge. He paced the tiny cell, his footsteps echoing. "Is this the end of it, then?" he whispered to the stone walls. "To be locked away until I am old?" He sank onto the rough straw pallet that served as a bed, burying his face in his hands. The waves crashed against the rock below, a relentless sound that seemed to mock his captivity.
Page 6
One night, David was woken by a faint scratching at his window. He looked out to see a rope dangling against the stone. Below, tossing on the dark sea, was a small boat. A familiar voice called up softly, "David, man! Are you coming, or do you enjoy the accommodations?" It was his friend, the Highlander Alan Breck Stewart, come secretly from France. Hope surged through David. He scrambled down the rough prison wall, his hands raw by the time he dropped into the boat where Alan pulled him aboard. "I heard you were in a bit of a scrape," Alan said with a grin, pressing an oar into his hands. "We need to be away before the tide turns." As they rowed silently into the darkness, away from the grim fortress, David asked, breathing heavily, "How did you ever find me?" Alan laughed quietly. "Och, I have my ways. And you, my friend, are terrible at keeping out of trouble."
Page 7
Alan smuggled David to Holland. With James Stewart now unjustly executed, David had no reason to risk returning to Scotland. He enrolled as a student at the famous University of Leiden, trying to build a new, quieter life. One afternoon, while walking through the city's neat, canal-lined streets, he heard a voice call his name. It was Catriona. She had come to Holland with her father, James More MacGregor, who was living in exile. David's joy at seeing her was immense, but it was complicated by her father's presence. James More was handsome and full of charm, but David saw something untrustworthy in his eyes. "Mr. Balfour!" James More declared, shaking his hand warmly. "My daughter has told me all about your kindness. We are deeply in your debt." "You are far from home, sir," David replied cautiously. "As are we all," said James More with a smile that didn't seem to reach his eyes.
Page 8
Their travels took them to Dunkirk. David had grown to love Catriona, but her father was a constant, unsettling presence. James More lived by borrowing money and spinning grand tales, and he began to use David's affection for his daughter to his own advantage. He tried to engineer a marriage, not for their happiness, but to get his hands on David's fortune. Finally, in a poor, sparsely furnished room at a Dunkirk inn, David confronted him. "You have been lying to your daughter and to me," David said, his voice tight with anger. "You see her only as a way to get money." James More, who had been pouring a drink, put the bottle down and his charming manner vanished. "And what if I do? She is my daughter to command. You will marry her and provide for us." David stood up, his fists clenched. "I love her too much to let you sell her. I will not be a party to your schemes."
Page 9
Hurt and confused by her father's lies, Catriona broke with David. But she soon saw James More's true, selfish nature for herself. Unable to bear his deceptions any longer, she finally left him. David, hearing she was alone and in difficulty, sought her out and found her walking on a dusty country road in France. The arguments and misunderstandings fell away as they met. "I was wrong to believe him," she said quietly, not looking at him. "I know that now." David came to her side. "He used us both," he said gently. "But he is behind us. Your path is your own." She stopped and finally looked at him, her eyes full of tears and relief. "I have no path, David. I do not know where to go." He reached out and took her hand. "Then let us make one together," he said. In that moment, on a lonely road far from home, they chose their future.
Page 10
In time, with the political dangers faded, David and Catriona were married and returned to Scotland. They did not go back to the smoky city, but to David's own lands in the Lowlands. From a gentle rise in the fields, they stood together and looked at the House of Shaws, its grey stone walls solid and welcoming under a Scottish sky. It was not a grand palace, but it was a home. After all their travels and dangers, they had found their way back. The quest for justice had cost much, but it had also led him here, to her. "It is a good place," Catriona said, her hand in his. "It is our home." David looked from the house to his wife's face and knew his adventures were finally over. "Welcome home, my dear," he said. A new life was beginning for the master of Shaws and his Highland bride.
About this story
- Audience: general readers
Read Wonder Novels on your phone
Wonder Novels is available on Android. Get Wonder Novels on Google Play.